View Full Version : Who designed the E34? and the answer is....
shogun
07-27-2005, 10:22 PM
Who designed important BMW cars in history?
BMW 1600/2002: Giovanni Michelotti
BMW 2500/2800: Giovanni Michelotti
BMW 507: Count Albrecht Goertz
BMW Touring: Giovanni Michelotti
BMW 3 series (1st and 2nd generation): Klaus Luthe
BMW 5 series (1st generation): Klaus Luthe with Ercole Spada
BMW 7 series (1st generation): Klaus Luthe with Ercole Spada
BMW Ml: Giorgetto Giugiaro
BMW Zl: Harm Lagaay
---------------
up to here the good guys, :p
All details are here
Crediting individual designers of production cars is a tricky business. But here is a list of the stylists generally acknowledged to have created the exterior designs of selected models.
2. Who designed important cars in history?
http://www.designet.ru/context-2003/c-cardesign-designers.shtml
digitaldragon03
07-27-2005, 10:26 PM
Uhh, it doesnt say who designed the e34.
shogun
07-27-2005, 10:27 PM
Correction: Claus Luthe, not Klaus
But Mr. Luthe was the Chief Designer at those days in BMW, and many give the real credit to J. Mays:
http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/showthread.php?t=17944&vm=r
"The VP of Global Design at Ford (J Mays, who worked on the design of the BMW E31, E34 and new GT40 among many others)"...
According to Roundel, Ercole Spada designed both the E32 7 Series and the E34 5 series.
However, the "1st generation" 5 Series, the E12, built from 1972-81, was designed by Paul Bracq. He also designed the E21 3 Series, E23 7 Series and the fabulous E24 6 Series.
To me, and this is really subject, arguably the best *looking* modern BMW is the E52 Z8, designed by Henrik Fisker (with some credit taken by our all time favorite designer, MR. CHRISTOPHER BANGLE)
Tcdoe
07-28-2005, 08:40 AM
Speaking of the 507, I don't think I ever realized what an absolutely beautiful car it is before I stumbled upon this picture:
http://members.optushome.com.au/abmw/post/1955_BMW_507_black.jpg
Kinda like an AC Cobra, but cooler. :) Makes me appreciate the Z8 a lot more.
Edit: Why stop at one picture:
http://www.automag.be/IMG/jpg/BMW_507.jpg
http://www.tapete-borte.de/Staud_web/images/BMW507003.jpg
Damn, I need one...
zygoteer
07-28-2005, 01:35 PM
Just out of interest, this is a scan I took from CAR magazine last year, it tells part of the story about Luthe
sorry pic didnt work ... trying again
Ok i shrunk it so much its not readable now :(
... working on it
zygoteer
07-28-2005, 02:01 PM
Maybe this will work now for the scan ... in three sections !
(hmm ... the pic on the right needs to be between ther other two )
This is interesting, if Claus Luthe was the *head* of BMW design, wouldn't it be the same as saying Chris Bangle, and not Henrik Fisker, designed the E52 Z8?
I stick by the July 2002 Roundel article that Ercola Spada, and NOT Claus Luthe or J. May designed the E34 5 Series!
DueyT
07-28-2005, 06:12 PM
I saw a reference to Ercola Spada and the E34 as well...just can't find the darn thing right now. >:-(
I saw a reference to Ercola Spada and the E34 as well...just can't find the darn thing right now. >:-(
Check out July 2002 Roundel, "BMW By Design", p. 40, 45.
DueyT
07-28-2005, 11:12 PM
Check out July 2002 Roundel, "BMW By Design", p. 40, 45.
Thanks, bfd, that's what I was remembering.
Cheers
Duey
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2024 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.