PDA

View Full Version : Immense Coolant leak from radiator neck



saj3n
12-02-2005, 11:40 AM
Seems as if the neck is broken, or was broken when I had the engine replaced. Is there a modification to repair this, or must a new radiator be installed?

shogun
12-02-2005, 11:44 AM
Replace it. Such repair does not last long and it will surely then break at the wrong place/time where you might even run in danger of a headgasket problem.

DaCan23
12-02-2005, 11:48 AM
Its a common thing, eventually everyones neck gets broken. You can find a Behr radiator for about $300, check BMA

saj3n
12-02-2005, 11:51 AM
Replace it. Such repair does not last long and it will surely then break at the wrong place/time where you might even run in danger of a headgasket problem.

Ok... Now for the search for a radiator..... :( I am going to try and get the shop to pay for it as it clearly did not have this problem before I took into the shop.

saj3n
12-02-2005, 12:23 PM
Ok... Now for the search for a radiator..... :( I am going to try and get the shop to pay for it as it clearly did not have this problem before I took into the shop.

Is there no method to replace the resovoir tank which the neck connects to?

DaCan23
12-02-2005, 01:42 PM
Perhaps pressure was applied to the area and it cracked, but good luck proving that, as they are known to break under normal use.

A few people over the years have repaird the neck, but cant remember a long term report on it.

But when my neck was broken, 2 times the hose blew off the radiator while driving on the highway... I wouldn't chance any repair that might cause that to happen again.

shogun
12-02-2005, 05:19 PM
I do not think the shop will pay for it. That stuff get's old and brittle and it was time to break. Be lucky that it happened there and not 500 miles away in the middle of nowhere.
My shop told me once when they started a repair, that old plastic parts could break as they are brittle and I should be prepared for this. I know it, Some months ago I wanted to change the parking light bulb and when I touched theat plastic rod, it just fell apart in pieces.

GS535i
12-02-2005, 06:08 PM
I purchased and replaced the end tank when the top hose spud broke off .... and they all will, in time. The aluminium crimps were real *#@$& to work with - but the rad lasted another 18 months. It died due to a poor gasket supplied with the end tank - so tossed it and replaced with a new rad. Seemingly a waste when the core was perfect ... but a reality in the world of plastic parts.

saj3n
12-03-2005, 01:08 AM
I purchased and replaced the end tank when the top hose spud broke off .... and they all will, in time. The aluminium crimps were real *#@$& to work with - but the rad lasted another 18 months. It died due to a poor gasket supplied with the end tank - so tossed it and replaced with a new rad. Seemingly a waste when the core was perfect ... but a reality in the world of plastic parts.

How much time & money did it set you back to replace the tank?

uscharalph
12-03-2005, 02:14 AM
Is there no method to replace the resovoir tank which the neck connects to?
Just the tank can be replaced (At least on mine). Is it the original radiator? If so just get a whole new one and know you won't have to deal with it for a while. You don't want to skimp when it come to the cooling system.

GS535i
12-03-2005, 06:53 AM
How much time & money did it set you back to replace the tank?

I sourced the tank through a radiator repair shop: installed, it was ~ $70. Sadly, the gasket was worth $0.02.